Branch vs Carbon vs Okash: which loan app is cheapest for a small loan? | TurnetFinance
Loan Apps

Branch vs Carbon vs Okash: which loan app is cheapest for a small loan?

Figures checked November 2026. Every rate and fee here carries its source and date. Loan app rates change fast, so re-check the figures in your own app before you accept any offer.

Branch vs Carbon vs Okash: which loan app is cheapest for a small loan?

Figures checked November 2026. Every rate and fee here carries its source and date. Loan app rates change fast, so re-check the figures in your own app before you accept any offer.

Quick answer: Branch, Carbon and Okash compared on the same small loan. On ₦50,000 for 3 months, Branch and Okash cost ₦54,500 and Carbon costs ₦56,750, but the fees tell a different story.

Branch, Carbon and Okash are three of the biggest names in Nigerian digital lending, and they are the three apps most borrowers compare first. Branch promises loans from 3 percent a month. Carbon promises a full banking app with loans inside it. Okash promises up to ₦3,000,000 from inside OPay. For a small loan, the differences between them are smaller than the adverts suggest, but they are not nothing. On ₦50,000 over three months, Branch and Okash both cost ₦54,500 in total, and Carbon costs ₦56,750. The gap is ₦2,250. But the fees, the late charges, and what happens when you repay early change the ranking completely.

This article compares the three on the same small loan, using each lender’s own published listing, explains where the guides disagree with the listings, and shows why the cheapest loan for ₦50,000 is not the cheapest loan for ₦100,000 over a year.

The three apps at a glance

BranchCarbonOkash
Lender behind itBranch International, licensed lending in NigeriaCarbon Microfinance Bank, RC 1642222, CBN-licensed MFBOPay Microfinance Bank Ltd, CBN-licensed
Amount range₦6,000 to ₦2,000,000₦25,000 to ₦1,000,000₦3,000 to ₦3,000,000
Tenor62 days to 12 months61 days to 12 months91 to 365 days
Published rateFrom 3% a month, APR 34 to 271%4.5 to 30% a month, max APR 195%3 to 15% a month, APR 36.5 to 360%
Own example₦1m over 12 months, ₦360,000 interest₦1m over 12 months at 4.5% flat, ₦1,540,000 total₦3,000 over 91 days, ₦273 interest

Branch: the steady one

Branch’s own listing gives ₦6,000 to ₦2,000,000, over 62 days to 12 months, from 3 percent a month, with an APR of 34 to 271 percent (Branch own listing via Oluboba, 18 Oct 2026). Its own example is ₦1,000,000 over 12 months at ₦113,333.33 a month, with ₦360,000 interest and a total of ₦1,360,000, which is 3 percent flat (Branch own listing, 18 Oct 2026). That example is the anchor for pricing Branch: 3 percent flat is the rate the lender itself uses to show borrowers what a loan costs.

The guides disagree with the listing on both the rate and the ceiling, and the disagreement is wide. The maximum amount is given as ₦2,000,000 by the own listing, ₦1,000,000 by one guide, and ₦500,000 by two others (Oluboba, InsuranceInfoFinder and CoinCola, Oct to Nov 2026). Your own offer will settle it, and the offer is the only rate that matters.


A dispatch rider checking a loan app while waiting for work

Carbon: the bank in your pocket

Carbon is the most complete product of the three, because it is a bank as well as a loan app. Its own listing gives ₦25,000 to ₦1,000,000, over 61 days to 12 months, at 4.5 to 30 percent a month, with a maximum APR of 195 percent (Carbon own listing via Oluboba and TechLoy, 18 to 23 Oct 2026). Its own example is ₦1,000,000 over 12 months at 4.5 percent flat, totalling ₦1,540,000, which is ₦540,000 in interest charged flat on the full principal (Carbon own listing, Oct 2026).

The guides disagree with the listing on the rate and the minimum. The minimum is given as ₦25,000 by the own listing, ₦2,500 by two guides, and ₦1,500 by two more (Oluboba, GrowFinance, OffCamp and InsuranceInfoFinder, Oct 2026). Use the own listing as the anchor: 4.5 to 30 percent a month, minimum ₦25,000.

Carbon’s weakness for a small loan is its flat rate and its early repayment rule. On a ₦1,000,000 loan at 4.5 percent flat over 12 months, repaying after six months saves nothing at all. The total stays ₦1,540,000 whether you pay in six months or twelve (carried from Batch 9 research). If you expect to repay early, Carbon’s flat rate gives you nothing for it.


Okash: the big ceiling

Okash is presented by OPay Microfinance Bank Limited, which was formerly Blue Ridge Microfinance Bank (Okash own Play listing, 21 Sep 2026). Its own Play listing gives ₦3,000 to ₦3,000,000, over 91 to 365 days, at 3 to 15 percent a month, with an APR of 36.5 to 360 percent, and interest calculated daily (Okash own Play listing, 21 Sep 2026). Its own example is ₦3,000 over 91 days with ₦273 interest and a total of ₦3,237, which is 9.1 percent interest over the 91 days.

The guides disagree with the listing on the maximum amount. The own listing says ₦3,000,000. Other sources say ₦1,000,000, ₦500,000, or ₦2,000,000 (InsuranceInfoFinder, MakeMoney, OffCamp and Brands.ng, 2025 to 2026). The older daily-rate figures are history. The current listing of 3 to 15 percent a month is the one to use, and the 9.1 percent per 91 days in its own example sits at the low end of that range.

Okash’s strengths are its ceiling and its entry point. It lends more than either rival, up to ₦3,000,000, and it takes the smallest first loans, from ₦3,000. Without a BVN, the guide range is ₦3,000 to ₦10,000, with a maximum of ₦500,000 without BVN against ₦2,000,000 with BVN (OffCamp, 2025). First loans are ₦3,000 to ₦20,000 according to Brands.ng (Jun 2026), or ₦3,000 to ₦30,000 according to AndroidPols (Sep 2026). The eligibility rules are Nigerian residency, age 20 to 55, a valid ID, an active bank account, and a stated source of income (Brands.ng, Jun 2026).


The same ₦50,000 for 3 months, three ways

LenderRate usedTotal repayment
Branch at 3% a monthFlat, own example rate₦54,500
Okash at 3% a monthFlat, low end of published range₦54,500
Okash at 9.1% per 91 daysOwn example rate₦54,550
Carbon at 4.5% a monthFlat, own example rate₦56,750
FairMoney representative exampleFlat, 10% a month₦65,000

Branch and Okash tie at ₦54,500. Okash’s own example rate gives ₦54,550, which is ₦50 more, because 9.1 percent over 91 days is a fraction above 3 percent a month flat. Carbon costs ₦56,750, which is ₦2,250 more than Branch and Okash. FairMoney‘s representative example costs ₦65,000, which is ₦10,500 more than Branch and Okash, and it is included to show that the three apps here are all cheaper than the most advertised loan app in the country on this loan size.

Verdict: for ₦50,000 over three months, Branch and Okash are joint cheapest at ₦54,500, and Carbon is ₦2,250 more at ₦56,750. The difference is small, so choose on the other factors: the late fee, the early repayment terms, and the limit you will be offered next.


The same ₦100,000 for 12 months, three ways

Stretch the loan to ₦100,000 over 12 months and the ranking widens. The flat rate punishes a long tenor more than a short one, and the reducing balance loan pulls ahead (computed, Python, 10 Nov 2026).

LenderRate usedTotal repayment
Renmoney at 2.49% a monthReducing, for comparison₦116,914
Branch at 3% a monthFlat₦136,000
Carbon at 4.5% a monthFlat₦154,000
Okash at 15% a monthFlat, high end of published range₦280,000

The 12-month table also shows why Carbon’s flat rate hurts more over a long tenor. At 4.5 percent flat, the interest is ₦54,000 on ₦100,000 over a year, which is more than half the principal. At 3 percent flat, Branch charges ₦36,000. Over 12 months, it is ₦18,000, and over the full term it is the difference between a loan you can afford and a loan that strains you. For a 12-month loan, the reducing balance lender wins by a wide margin, and among the three flat-rate apps, the lowest flat rate wins.


The small-loan trap: when the fee costs more than the interest

On a small loan, the fee can cost more than the interest, and this is where Branch, Carbon and Okash differ most. Take ₦20,000 for 30 days (computed, Python, 10 Nov 2026). Branch at 3 percent flat charges ₦600 in interest. Carbon at 4.5 percent flat charges ₦900. Okash at 3 percent charges ₦600. Those are small numbers, and any of the three looks affordable.

Now add the fees. A 15 percent processing fee on ₦20,000 is ₦3,000, which is five times the ₦600 interest on the Branch loan. FairMoney also charges a flat ₦1,000 late fee, which alone is 5 percent of a ₦20,000 loan (published, carried from Batch 9 research). GTBank QuickCredit charges 1 percent credit insurance (GTBank own page, Oct 2026).

The point is not that Branch, Carbon and Okash charge these fees. Before you accept a ₦20,000 loan, read the Key Facts Statement, which the DEON Regulations require lenders to give you (Nairametrics, 9 Sep 2026), and add up the principal, the interest and every fee. If the fees exceed the interest, the loan is priced on its charges, not on its rate, and you should compare the grand total, not the monthly percentage.


A recharge card seller at her kiosk checking her phone

Early repayment: who rewards you and who does not

Early repayment is where Carbon loses and Branch and Okash hold their ground, though none of the three is perfect. On a ₦1,000,000 Carbon loan at 4.5 percent flat over 12 months, repaying after six months saves nothing. The total stays ₦1,540,000 (carried from Batch 9 research). If you expect a lump sum during the loan, a bonus, a contract payment, or a family contribution, Carbon gives you no benefit for paying early.

Compare that with the wider market. And on a reducing balance loan, early repayment always saves money: repaying a ₦1,000,000 Renmoney loan at 2.49 percent reducing after six months saves about ₦47,743 (carried from Batch 9 research). Check the early repayment terms before you borrow, not after, because by then the interest is already fixed.


Late fees: what a missed payment costs on each app

The late fee is the least transparent part of this comparison, because two of the three apps do not publish one. Branch’s listing says only that some customers may incur a late fee, with no amount attached (Oluboba, 18 Oct 2026). Carbon’s late fee in its current own-listing terms is also not published; only older guide figures exist, of ₦100 a day and a 10 percent collection fee on unpaid amounts, which should be treated as guide figures, not current terms (EmpowermentHub, 13 Mar 2024).

What is published elsewhere in the market shows the range. FairMoney charges a flat ₦1,000 late fee (published, carried from Batch 9 research). The CBN Guide to Charges caps penal interest at 1 percent flat a month, with a seven-day grace period for banks and three days for microfinance banks, and the daily rollovers sit far above that cap, a dispute that is not settled (carried from Batch 10 research).


Which one should you pick?

For a small loan of ₦50,000 over three months, Branch and Okash tie at ₦54,500, and Carbon costs ₦56,750. The difference is ₦2,250, so the choice should turn on the other factors. Okash is the most flexible on amount, from ₦3,000 to ₦3,000,000, and the easiest to enter without a BVN for a very small first loan (AndroidPols, 18 Sep 2026). Carbon is the most complete product, a licensed microfinance bank with NDIC-insured deposits, top-ups, and bureau reporting that builds your credit score, but its flat rate gives you nothing for early repayment (Carbon help centre, accessed Nov 2026, and OffCamp, 2025 to 2026).

For a longer loan of ₦100,000 over 12 months, the ranking widens: Branch at ₦136,000, Carbon at ₦154,000, and Okash anywhere from ₦136,000 at the low end of its range to ₦280,000 at the high end. But a reducing balance lender beats all three: Renmoney at 2.49 percent reducing totals ₦116,914 on the same loan (computed, Python, 10 Nov 2026). If you need ₦100,000 for a year, compare a bank-backed reducing loan before you settle on any of these three apps.


A couple reviewing household finances together at home

Funmi’s Story: the ₦600 that became ₦4,000

Funmi is an illustrative example. She is a 24-year-old student at Obafemi Awolowo University in Ile-Ife who borrowed ₦20,000 from a loan app for 30 days to buy textbooks before her exams. The app advertised 3 percent a month, so she expected to pay ₦600 in interest and ₦20,600 in total.

The offer she accepted carried a 15 percent processing fee, which was ₦3,000, taken from the loan before it reached her. She received ₦17,000, not ₦20,000, and she still had to repay ₦20,600. Then her allowance arrived two days late, and the app charged a flat ₦1,000 late fee. Her ₦600 of interest had become ₦4,000 in fees, which was more than six times the interest, and more than the textbooks would have cost if she had waited a week and borrowed from a friend instead.

Funmi’s rule now is to read the Key Facts Statement before she accepts any loan, and to add the fees to the interest before she compares. On a ₦20,000 loan, the fee is the price, not the interest. She also sets her repayment date two days before her allowance arrives, so a delay never makes her late.


Frequently Asked Questions

Which is cheapest for a small loan: Branch, Carbon or Okash?

On ₦50,000 over three months, Branch and Okash both total ₦54,500, and Carbon totals ₦56,750 (computed, Python, 10 Nov 2026). The gap is ₦2,250. But the fees and the early repayment terms can change the ranking, so compare the grand total including fees, not just the interest, and read the Key Facts Statement before you accept.

Why is Carbon more expensive even though its rate looks similar?

Because Carbon charges its interest flat on the full principal for the whole term, and its own help centre says early repayment does not reduce the total payable (Carbon help centre, accessed Nov 2026). On ₦100,000 over 12 months, Carbon at 4.5 percent flat totals ₦154,000, against Branch at 3 percent flat totalling ₦136,000 and Renmoney at 2.49 percent reducing totalling ₦116,914 (computed, Python, 10 Nov 2026).

Can I borrow less than ₦25,000 from Carbon?

Not according to its own listing, which gives a minimum of ₦25,000 (Carbon own listing, Oct 2026). Guides give lower minimums of ₦2,500 or ₦1,500, but the own listing is the anchor. Branch starts at ₦6,000 and Okash at ₦3,000, so for a very small loan, either of those is the better choice (own listings, Sep to Oct 2026).

What happens if I repay my Carbon loan early?

Nothing is saved. Carbon’s own help centre says early repayment is accepted but does not reduce the total payable, because the flat interest is fixed for the full term (Carbon help centre, accessed Nov 2026). On a ₦1,000,000 loan, the total stays ₦1,540,000 whether you pay in six months or twelve. On a reducing balance loan, repaying a ₦1,000,000 Renmoney loan after six months saves about ₦47,743 (carried from Batch 9 research).

Do Branch, Carbon and Okash report to the credit bureaus?

Carbon reports positive repayments to the credit bureaus, which helps build a credit score (OffCamp, 2025 to 2026). Lenders generally report loan performance monthly, and by Day 30 a missed payment will likely have been formally submitted (SharpCollect, Oct 2026). The negative record lasts 3 to 7 years depending on the source, with a CBN maximum of 6 years (LoanSharkReview, 3 Apr 2026).

Are Branch, Carbon and Okash licensed?

Yes. All three are on the FCCPC‘s approved list, and the register lists 525 fully approved digital lenders as of 21 October 2026 (TechCity tally). The FCCPC’s warning of 3 November 2026 names 12 blacklisted apps to avoid: Cashlawn, Easynaira, Crediting, Yoyi, Nut Loan, Cashpal, Camelloan, Soko Loan, 9ja Cash, Get Cash, Fast Money and Go Cash (InsideBusiness, 3 Nov 2026). Check any lender on the register at fccpc.gov.ng before you borrow.


The Bottom Line

Branch, Carbon and Okash are all licensed, all fast, and all cheaper than the most advertised loan app on a small loan. On ₦50,000 over three months, Branch and Okash tie at ₦54,500 and Carbon costs ₦56,750. The gap is small, so the choice should turn on what matters to you: Branch for steadiness and predictable growth, Okash for the widest range of amounts and the easiest entry, Carbon for a full banking app that builds your credit score but gives you nothing for early repayment. Over 12 months, the ranking widens, and a reducing balance lender like Renmoney beats all three at ₦116,914 on ₦100,000.

Before you borrow from any of them, run the numbers on the Loan App Comparator, type in the rate from your own offer, and compare the total repayment including every fee. Then check the lender on the FCCPC register at fccpc.gov.ng and read the Key Facts Statement. On a small loan, the fee can cost more than the interest, and the cheapest loan is the one with the smallest grand total, not the smallest headline rate.

Related: Best Loan Apps in Nigeria 2026: Ranked by Interest Rate | Best Loan Apps in Nigeria 2026: The Honest Guide Before You Borrow | How to Save Money on Food in Nigeria

Share this guideWhatsAppXFacebook
Abraham Adebisi
Abraham Adebisi
Founder, TurnetFinance

Abraham Adebisi is the founder of TurnetFinance. He builds free finance tools and writes honest guides about money in Nigeria, from land and rent to loans and saving.

About Abraham →

Money sense, weekly.

New tools, app reviews and guides in your inbox. Free, with no spam.

A smiling Nigerian businesswoman
TurnetFinance

Place your business in front of over 3,000 monthly users

Money-minded Nigerians come here to decide. Reach them while they’re paying attention.

Book your spot